Sibley Square
Information about Sibley Square
Opening hours
- sunday: (closed)
- monday: 8:30-17:30
- tuesday: 8:30-17:30
- wednesday: 8:30-17:30
- thursday: 8:30-17:30
- friday: 8:30-17:30
- saturday: (closed)
Rent at Sibley Square Apartments in Rochester, NY! These apartments are conveniently located near fine dining. Call us!
The Mercantile on Main is Sibley's restaurant marketplace, featuring regional cuisine from local chefs is NOW OPEN! Located at 240 East Main Street in the 5 story, 10,000 square foot atrium.
Sibley Square: Reviews
Fantastic experience: Gorgeous environment
Hi,
Thank you for your kind review! We’re so glad you’re enjoying the beautiful environment at Sibley Square—it’s something we take great pride in.
We truly appreciate your support!
Positive experience: I have done a nice job with Sibley; however the neighborhood is still very sketchy. I would not go there unless I was downtown for something else.
Fantastic experience: Excelente
Hi Yeymy, thank you for posting your positive review. Our team here at Sibley Square is committed to providing high-quality customer service, and we’re thrilled to hear that we made a good impression on you. We hope you’ll visit us again soon.
Fantastic experience: Great to b in downtown cup coffee
Fantastic experience: Very nice, well kept historical building.
Hello Philip, We're delighted to hear about your experience! We're always happy to help so don't hesitate to contact us if you ever need anything. We'll be sure to share your experience with the rest of our team members as inspiration! We look forward to seeing you again soon.
Fantastic experience: Great space with so much history. You can see evidence throughout the building of the space being reinvented with respect for the building's history.
Fantastic experience: They have so many nice restaurants in the lobby, extremely different from when mcc was here
Fantastic experience: The best handmade lunch! Can't wait to go back!
Fantastic experience: I went to the dentist there and it was dope inside still looks like a mall center or something lol
Hey Amy, Thanks for the great review!
Fantastic experience: Took a rochester brainery cooking class here.great space
Dear Karen, Thanks for the kind words!
Fantastic experience: Great repurpose of an iconic Downtown Rochester landmark
Positive experience: Apartments are nice but a little bit pricy
Fantastic experience: Lots to do here!
Fantastic experience: It's so nice to see the sibly building all decorated.For christmas such a nice historical place for rochester. I remember coming here as a child and riding the monorail!!!
Positive experience: The emptiness of the building is sad, but the FOCUS THEATER on 3rd floor , 5 STARS.
Thank you for the review. We are working hard to revitalize the entire building, and we hope you will check back to see the progress! We hope you come back soon, and again, thank you for the review.
- Sibley Square Management Team
Positive experience: Historical!
We agree! We are doing our best to preserve the history! Thank you for the positive review.
- Sibley Square Management Team
Positive experience: I went to this space for an emergency dental procedure at Eastman Dental. I went in the wrong door at first and found apartments. The building has changed a lot from what I remembered. There was a retail store in there. I am not sure, but after that store closed, I think it became more of a mixed space. Once, there was a college. It also had some retail stores and other businesses. Now there is more of a mix and very nice inside.
Fantastic experience: Going to the bank
Positive experience: The good here is wonderful. The daycare her is Top Notch! It's nice to see this all downtown
Dear Dr. Heather, Thank you for the positive review! We are so glad that you found our daycare top notch! We hope to see you again soon! Thanks again!
Fantastic experience: Great place to shop and eat
Positive experience: A nice building with its age, a shame to no longer have are mall/plaza anymore..
Positive experience: Cool place with a cool vibe.
Positive experience: Employees are extremely kind and helpful. I love the well thought out and colorful displays. My coffee was perfect. Fries were cooked to my liking.
Negative experience: Nice, but they raise their tenants rent very often. #greed
Fantastic experience: Went to see What was left from the sibley tower display. Hard for me to get there do to parking issues. But to me to see I payed the price the next
Hi James, We are so happy to hear that you visited Sibley Square. We do have two parking garages available for parking as well - the Mortimer Street Garage and St. Joes Garage. Thank you for the kind review and we hope you visit again!
Fantastic experience: Nice apts.
Fantastic experience: Nice and clean...love the UR medicine clinic
Positive experience: Retail & residential
w
Positive experience: We were at Sibley Square to attend The Focus Theater. It's fabulous to see some revitalization happening in the building and several spaces put to good use (if you enjoy performing arts, we recommend the theater!) We do wish there was better signage. When we entered the building from the Mortimer Street Garage, we found it challenging to find the theater. We hope to see more spaces in the building filled. We'll definitely be back to eat at The Mercantile on Main!
Positive experience: I have not seen them but the amenities are amazing. A bit pricey however you get what you pay for. Downtown living @ it's fineness.
Thank you, Zanetta, for the positive review. We have several different communities within Sibley Square and hope you will visit us! Winn Management Team.
Positive experience: Some tasty food and a lovely space to catch up with friends and colleagues.
Positive experience: It was okay because I went to the Mercantile on main. But it also made me nostalgic for the old days when Sibley's was still a store in Rochester. Seeing the old Sibley's signage got me to remembering all the stores we have lost since then. Rochester at one time was a mecca of shopping centers and stores, all in the city. I just hope that they never change the name of the building. We should always remember the Sibley's Building and all it did for Rochester at one time.
Positive experience: Commissary Que Chevere Delicious Spanish food
Fantastic experience: I love RoCoCo Coffee! The restaurants here have some Tasty dishes. I enjoy doing the weekend markets here. Nkce crowd of people always come through.
Positive experience: Nice food hall
Positive experience: Good experience food was great if you are looking for something different. Nice bar area and other interesting businesses surrounding the food court.
Positive experience: Made for an interesting visit. Main drawback was we walked over and it would have helped to have more info at the first door we tried. The place has more than one door to get in and there was wet weather.
Fantastic experience: Tienen variedad de comidas.
Thank you for the positive review and 5 Stars!
Fantastic experience: Great
Fantastic experience: This is one of the last great downtown buildings, and I love the combination of old and new here.
Dear Shannon, Thanks so much for taking the time to share your positive feedback!
Fantastic experience: Great living area and great food court
Fantastic experience: Building is clean and modern.
Positive experience: Nice place
Fantastic experience: So awesome to see a little bit of the old downtown still around
Fantastic experience: The bank accepted my account. Lol.
Negative experience: Some years ago . When my son was like 3or 4years old his coat got stuck in the escalator and I reported to them and they didn't do nothing about it. Totally ruined my son coat . I had to get him another one.
Fantastic experience: It's not like old days down town.
Fantastic experience: Sibley square is a classic Rochester, New York location. They are currently holding the French festival. The area is bustling with local shops and establishments. I would recommend visiting the area if you are in the downtown Rochester area.
Negative experience: 46 year old security gaurd Elliott Adell is a p*dophile and r*pist, there is evidence and the victim has come forward. Police know but Elliot is still working here and walking free.
Positive experience: It's was ok.
Fantastic experience: Awesome
Fantastic experience: Really cool
Positive experience: It's a nice building and it's helping a lot of people that can't afford to live any other place their subsidized housing is very nice
Fantastic experience: Love the new look and how they remolded the inside.
Fantastic experience: Absolutely gorgeous!
Positive experience: Its ok for a quick stop for some random items from the shop and there's a Dollar General next door which is convenient for quick grocery item stop and some other odds and ends.
Positive experience: Sibley square is in a central downtown location with easy access to banking and restaurants
Fantastic experience: Love the ambience
Positive experience: Classic building
Positive experience: Nice place went late in day and most merchants were closed.
Negative experience: Would be nice to see police officers around to enhance security and safety.
Positive experience: Love the city and all it has to say.
Fantastic experience: Lovely historic building, rooftop with amazing views of the city
Positive experience: Nice work space
Fantastic experience: I walk to the DG in the Square, they have a great store. A great selection and very clean store. The people are helpful and respectful. Love this store.
Fantastic experience: Check it out! You'll be surprised at what is there!
Fantastic experience: Pretty cool how they are redoing the entire building! Worth checking out.
Fantastic experience: Awesome
Fantastic experience: Always a nice building to visit and be in
Positive experience: Very historical place, I was there 45 years ago as a kid for all of the holiday displays. Great memories and de of the original fixtures are still on display. Small but growing food court.
Positive experience: C300
Fantastic experience: Beautiful Renovations. New small businesses. Great coffee ☕ & food.
Fantastic experience: Wonderful place people were nice.
Fantastic experience: Great place for getting together with friends or even just getting out of the house in general. 5 restaurants, a cafe and bar all in one!
Positive experience: Nice place great stores and restaurants
Positive experience: Neat area for downtown.
Fantastic experience: Still the same tower growing up. Except a 180 degree difference. From being a kid crossing the bridge into Midtown. Shopping with my parents with the different levels in Sibleys. A lot has changed downtown. I just hope when it's all finished it's value is greater not a loss. Place is secured with shops on ground floor apartments up above. They have a lot too offer including a dog area inside in 2nd floor. Overall it's nice except parking garage got drug users and homeless in it. Otherwise Street parking is limited. Should of built garage on backside of building were tenants can park on there floor and still have ground floor entrance
Fantastic experience: I miss the old Sibley's store
Fantastic experience: Looks nice but, reminds me of gentrification. You didnt see the people you see there now about 6, 7 years ago
Fantastic experience: You have to checkout Sibley Square. It is a new place! They have Eateries at the main floor, banks, Eastman dental is still there and RIT Art room. They also have this beautiful senior care hospital next to Eastman dental. Then, they have their beautiful apartments that I've toured. It's pricey but they have two options. I'm really happy how the place turned out. Glad they got rid of Rainbows. I use to go there for the shuttle to MCC Brighton and took one class at the downtown one in Sibley. I was afraid they would go dormant. They have such a beautiful history. They use to decorate the window beautifully for Christmas. It made me so happy
Fantastic experience: Good atmosphere
Fantastic experience: Was able to relax and eat
Fantastic experience: This has to be seen to be believed! The Sibley's Building is being renovated into shopping/living/senior living/high-end apartments and more with views of the city like no other building in Rochester!!
Fantastic experience: Walk through and bank
Fantastic experience: Love seeing this building coming back strong
Fantastic experience: Great building under renovation. New places to eat, shop and live. Check out the DGx, just opening on 11/23.
Negative experience: Need more cleaning
Fantastic experience: All Aces
Fantastic experience: I go to the dentist there even though people live there now I think them that they kept the dentist in the downtown location
Fantastic experience: Big beautiful bldg. Soon there will be a canteen. Will be Open to the public. Soon a bar There's 3 leasing offices Liberty lofts, Spectra, Landmark. Eastman dental, life span R.I.T art Space
Negative experience: I don't hate this place i love it it's so beautiful in that place the only thing i don't like from there is the rent amount. But it's ok cause it has so many things in there for entertainment & the apartments are spacious & beautiful plus there going to start soon a cafeteria & stores lots of fun there but the amount of rent high there its okay cause there's lots of things there for entertainments like i said i love it.
Positive experience: It's not what I remember growning up I miss down town shopping getting fresh cook peanuts and others shops of good eating and visiting window shopping that's looking at this in the desplay and thinking of buying.
Positive experience: Great downtown location!
Positive experience: It's always clean even though it is Huge
Positive experience: Fine
Positive experience: It's really cool to see what they did with this space -- it looks awesome! I have fond memories of the walk from the Frontier Bldg to the Sibley Food Court (back in the day)! The place is still under construction. I toured the space after inquiring about a hot seat / no assigned desk in the Sibley Worx area and Winn Companies' best offer was $150 month + parking. That seems really steep to me for a place that currently looks partly deserted. Some marketing efforts make me scratch my head in disbelief. Good luck!
Fantastic experience: Beautiful
Fantastic experience: Good
Fantastic experience: Very comfy, loving spaces are up stairs and everything else is downstairs. Shopping and living all in one
Positive experience: Good
Leave your opinion about Sibley Square:
Sibley Square appears in the following listings:
Other real estate agencies you might be interested in
Maison Management, Inc
The Jeff Scofield Team Real Estate Agents
Cook Properties
Add your real estate agency to our directory for free
If you manage a real estate agency and want to appear in our guide, send us your company information and you can appear completely free of charge.