Real Property Management Steel City

Fantastic experience: I love this property it is perfect for my little family! AMAZING help from real property management! they are amazing at making their tenants feel comfortable in their homes! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Fantastic experience: Very good communication, makes living here feel like home, great neighbors and a calm environment. Can’t wait to see what it brings in the future

Fantastic experience: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ A.J. Amato, Property Manager with Real Property Management of Steel City, is truly exceptional at what she does. She consistently looks out for both her tenants and property owners with integrity, professionalism, and everyone’s best interests in mind. A.J. is committed to doing things the right way and ensuring that all work is completed properly and up to code, which speaks volumes about her standards and accountability. Her communication with contractors and vendors is outstanding. She stays on top of every detail, making coordination seamless and our jobs significantly easier. It’s clear that she values strong working relationships and understands how important clear, timely communication is to keeping projects moving smoothly. Working with A.J. is always a positive experience, and her dedication to ethical property management truly sets her apart. Highly recommend!

Fantastic experience: I had a very positive experience working with this property management team. They were professional, responsive, and communicated clearly throughout the process. When my situation changed unexpectedly, they handled everything with understanding and courtesy. I especially appreciated how promptly they returned my cashier’s check and kept me updated along the way. Their professionalism and kindness made a stressful situation much easier. I would definitely recommend them to anyone looking for a company that treats people with respect.

Fantastic experience: Always prompt and get stuff done on time, responsive and follow through

Fantastic experience: AJ is always great to deal with, always nice and very helpful!

Fantastic experience: My experience withRPM steel city has been amazing. The dedication and hard work they do has blessed me so much. It is so wonderful to have a team that I can rely upon to care for my property handling the myriad of details flawlessly and giving me such a clear and detailed accounting for my investment.

Fantastic experience: Amazing company. Never had an issue, and they are really on top of things if there's ever a need. If they have another property that fits my needs when my lease is up, i would love to stay renting from them

Positive experience: I considered working with Real Property Management but was not able to move forward after reviewing their agreement. While initial conversations suggested flexibility with my home warranty and maintenance involvement the contract reflected a very different structure which gave the company full control while leaving much of the liability with the owner. The fee structure also lacked clear specificity which raised concerns about potential costs. When I proposed a written addendum to clarify expectations around maintenance, fees, and defined responsibilities they declined and stated they do not modify their agreement. This may work for fully hands-off landlord's but owners who want transparency, defined responsibilities, and some level of control should review the agreement carefully before signing.

Fantastic experience: Excellent property management company! The whole team is very professional, knowledgeable, and well organized. I have been working mainly with Lesha and Carlo, and both of them have been tremendously helpful and responsive. I would certainly recommend this property management company to both - tenants and property owners, if you want things done effectively and efficiently.

Fantastic experience: Very nice and helping person Edna had great customer and was very helpful with the move in process definitely recommend

Fantastic experience: We had the pleasure of renting this home for a full year, and it truly exceeded our expectations. From the moment we walked in, it felt warm, welcoming, and instantly like home. The colors throughout the house are so creative and fun—they give the space a unique personality while still feeling cozy and inviting. One of our absolute favorite features was the fireplace. It made the home feel extra special and created the perfect spot to relax and unwind. The neighborhood is incredibly quiet, with respectful neighbors that made us feel comfortable and at peace the entire time. It’s such a calm and safe environment, which we really appreciated. The schools in the area are amazing as well, which is a huge bonus for families. The yard is huge and offers plenty of space to enjoy the outdoors, and the views of the mountains are simply breathtaking. Waking up to that scenery never got old. AJ Amato was an absolute pleasure to work with. She made everything so easy and welcoming, and always answered any questions we had. The only reason we moved is because we ended up buying a home—otherwise, we would have happily stayed. Overall, this home is something special. It combines comfort, beauty, and a peaceful location in a way that’s hard to find. We are so grateful for our time here and would absolutely recommend it to anyone looking for a place that truly feels like home.

Fantastic experience: Great walk through! She was super sweet and answered all of our questions/concerns.

Fantastic experience: So far so good the application process went really well and after all the applications I put in with all the different companies. They got back to me first. They have stayed in contact with me the entire step if the way. Made every step easy and fit my schedule. Worked with to the very best of their abilities. And like I said before constant communication. Which I love. And I absolutely adore Edna. I think I am going to like it here. Xoxo

Fantastic experience: Great communication and have a way of feeling like your worries and questions are prioritized.

Fantastic experience: We have lived in the home we are renting for a year and a half, and hope we can stay here as long as possible. Finding a place through Real Property Management Steel City has been a great experience for our family.The whole process to apply, get approved, and move in was seamless, easy, and straightforward. Their team is very responsive to any needs we have and are always personable. We have even recommended RPM-SC to homeowners who are thinking about renting their home out! I highly recommend RPM Steel City to anyone looking for a place to rent or homeowners who want to rent their property but not have to deal with the business side of it .

Fantastic experience: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5-Star Review I have had a great experience working with Real Property Management Steel City. Their team is professional, responsive, and organized, which makes it easy for vendors like myself to complete work efficiently and on time. Communication has been clear and consistent, and work orders are detailed, allowing me to understand exactly what is needed before arriving on site. This level of coordination helps ensure quality service and smooth project completion. As a vendor for Flyer-4-Hire Distribution LLC, I truly appreciate the opportunity to work with a company that values professionalism and reliability. It makes a big difference in the field. I look forward to continuing our working relationship and highly recommend Real Property Management Steel City to anyone seeking dependable property management services. — Pearl Padilla, Managing Member Flyer-4-Hire Distribution LLC

Fantastic experience: Awesome landlord! Very friendly and helpful staff! Always gets things done as soon as possible! Both Lesha and Carlo have made it easy to ask for help and make us feel like family instead of tenants.

Fantastic experience: Annual inspections with AJ Amato went great felt heard, always a pleasant interaction!

Fantastic experience: We couldn’t be more happy with Real Property Management. They have taken great care of our home for almost the last two years and have kept us up to date on everything related to our property. They have high standards for when they vet potential tenants which led to us having amazing tenants. We would recommend Real Property Management all day every day to anyone needing a great company to care for their property.

Fantastic experience: Love this company so far, application process and move-in is very straightforward and as they explain it. These foos work with you no matter how "needy" you may seem. My family is no-budget from the bad side so we are used to dealing with by-owner places. These people treated us like people, not just a credit score, from viewing to signing and I appreciate that. At first I felt foolish for applying but after the second call with RPM Steel City we were able to breathe and not waste money on applying at 4 places just to lose the fee money, we just waited on this ONE app because we thought it was OK and BAM!! Got a move-in within a business week and absolutely LOVE dealing with our Property Management. Just be a good and upfront tenant....they are good and upfront people. Lease seems extensive but when you're moving up you gotta be willing to treat a rental like a new buy, and that's where we are, next step on the path to our own owned home thanks to RPM Steel City. (From drug infested trailer park on 2400 block of lake ave in pueblo's Grea-hea-easey side of town to a good home vibes house) Ceud mile taing from the Watts family

Fantastic experience: Tremendous customer service. I have rented from atleast half a dozen property management companies and Real Property Management is head and shoulders above the rest.

Fantastic experience: Just moving in, process took less than 5 days (over weekend) We are very new and nervous to the whole process and have always dealt with background discrimination (live on the cheap end of town) Every person and every step of the process with RPM Steel City has been amazing. No one can see the future but we are very excited to start our tenancy with RPM Steel city.

Fantastic experience: Great properties and great staff, communication and reliability in real property management

Fantastic experience: Great property managers from a tenants perspective. They are quick to respond and take pride in the homes they manage

Fantastic experience: They helped me with everything. Answered every question I had and got me my place I appreciate everyone who helped me out

Negative experience: ZERO STARS! We recently signed a lease for a property managed by this company, but during our initial walkthrough immediately after receiving the keys, we discovered multiple issues that made us uncomfortable proceeding with the tenancy. The property did not appear to have received a full turnover cleaning. Ceiling fans were very dirty, floors were unclean, and there were visible furniture marks in the carpet. There were also items left behind from previous occupants in the basement and yard, including debris and miscellaneous belongings. Additionally, we noticed maintenance and security concerns such as a missing storm door key, a damaged gate that could not be secured, and an extremely loud bathroom fan. The garage also had a strong oil or chemical odor. We documented everything right away and communicated promptly, but ultimately chose to withdraw because the property did not appear move-in ready. And we weren’t not given a timeline of when it would be fixed so that we could move in. I strongly recommend that prospective tenants request or conduct a detailed walkthrough before signing or accepting keys to ensure the property is in acceptable condition. Our experience may not reflect everyone’s, but thorough documentation and inspection are very important. The deposit was ultimately returned, though the process felt somewhat rigid and stressful.

Fantastic experience: Great service !! Awesome and beautiful homes !!

Fantastic experience: Ive been with Real Property Management for a while now and must say that any questions or mantinace I needed done was always met with very professional and very helpful answers and a BIG BIG THANK YOU to AJ Amato for all the help.

Fantastic experience: Real Property Management Steel City has made our move so easy and convenient, and AJ Amato has been absolutely great helping us out with anything we need!

Fantastic experience: I had a fantastic experience with the whole team at Real Property Management! They communicated clearly and quickly. They were very professional and understanding about anything that came up. It's been great working with them!!

Fantastic experience: very easy to work with, very fast and easy, very helpful and amazing people to work with

Fantastic experience: Very personable, professional, and well organized. This is by far the best company I have worked with. They all make you feel safe and comfortable. Very responsive and just awesome! AJ is the best!!

Fantastic experience: The staff at RPM. has been very friendly and helpful. A.j is very respectful. We were able to schedule a time to do a walk thru very easily that worked for us both. She was very professional and made the entire experience comfortable and easy . Any problems that have arose were addressed and fixed in less than 24 hrs in most cases. Love that we are able to bring up anything and they fix it so fast . Thanks again A.J. for making us feel at ease with any questions or changes that have arose.

Fantastic experience: She was kind and me if everything worked properly a few times. She heard my concerns and gave me advice on what to do next.

Fantastic experience: I would like to say AJ Amato is great and I enjoy her coming to do my property inspections! She always asks if I have any questions or concerns about anything! Great and very helpful! Thank you AJ!

Fantastic experience: Always fast and attentive to every problem the maintenance team especially Codah goes above and beyond Every one is always polite and friendly great team to rent from or manage your property

Fantastic experience: Wonderful staff working there! Respectful nice and willing to help you with what ever you need.

Fantastic experience: Codah is always so friendly and polite. I ask him questions and he responds if he knows. Great worker!

Fantastic experience: Good communication

Fantastic experience: This company is good, they get things done in a timely manner. Aj is very nice and professional.

Positive experience: Read the lease agreement and it was very landlord friendly but not so much on the tenant side. This company gets great reviews from the property owners but I’m glad I read the lease and did not sign.

Negative experience: I am extremely disappointed with this company. They advertise a response time of 2–3 business days, yet I never received any real answer. They took my money, and despite making several calls and leaving multiple messages, no one ever got back to me. The one time I did reach Edna, she simply said, “We’re still working on it and will let you know,” but I never heard anything after that. They took my money—money that people these days do not just have lying around to throw away—and provided absolutely nothing in return. Not even a simple letter or email saying “thanks but no thanks.” It’s very sad and frustrating, especially for people who are desperate to move and just trying to find a safe, stable home for their families. No one should be left in the dark like this. Terrible communication and an overall disappointing experience.

Fantastic experience: Very knowledgeable and professional.

Fantastic experience: Great management team and very supportive (: (:

Fantastic experience: I have had some really bad experiences with property management companies in Colorado. But dealing with Real Property Management has been a breeze. We needed to move in a pinch and they were there for me and my family when it mattered. We truly appreciate you guys.

Positive experience: Respectful, kind. Quick to address any Maintenance issues and have them completed. Fair and honest. My family and I haven’t been renting from this management company for very long, however they have been great. We needed a quicker move in date and they definitely went out of their way to get us in to a beautiful home. Everyone at the office is kind, professional, and proficient.

Positive experience: It has been a challenge to get a return phone call from Brady. It is hard to find people that provide good customer service these days. Edna has helped so much. She is always kind and helpful. She truly understands what customer service should be.

Fantastic experience: Great so far! Moved in summer 2025 to an RPM-managed property.

Fantastic experience: We recently switched both of our Pueblo rentals over to Steel City, and they’ve been amazing. From day one they were upfront with us about what needed to be done to get the properties ready and what rent prices made sense for the market. They took excellent photos, stayed in constant communication, and made everything smooth and stress-free. Our previous management company required potential tenants to complete an application and pay a fee before they could even see a property, which created waaay too much friction to make good business sense. It’s no surprise our places weren't getting many showings. Steel City does business professionally and made the process simple for potential renters, as a result our properties rented shortly after being listed. I could not be more pleased. I’m very happy we made the switch and you will be too.

Positive experience: My experience Started kind of rough but AJ really knows what she is doing and made it better in the end. After she took over the process it became quick and easy and I felt far more at ease.

Fantastic experience: We have had a great experience with customer service and the team overall. I would recommend this property management company to anyone seeking to rent/buy a property.

Fantastic experience: Everyone has been extremely helpful and kind. Would recommend!

Fantastic experience: Been easy to work with. And great service!

Fantastic experience: Aj was just awesome she was on time and very nice very professional and very helpful

Fantastic experience: Profesionales,amables,siempre atentos a responder cualquier consulta

Fantastic experience: Very kind and professional

Fantastic experience: The management Team was very helpful during the entire process and easy to talk to.

Fantastic experience: Never had an issue with them over 4 years and the online house inspection is wonderful.

Negative experience: Wish I could give 0 stars to this company that has refused to give me my deposit back for normal wear and tear issues. Not to mention less than a year living in one of there rentals my house was broken into while I was asleep with my small children because they had a bedroom door knob on the front door. This company takes advantage of the pueblo people and has little to no respect for young owners that needs explanation. They refuse to call me due to my "tone" in my voicemail when I never once swore or used derogatory words. WHATEVER YOU DO, DO NOT TRUST THIS COMPANY. The 950.00 that was kept is not needed but its about the simple fact that they treat us pueblo people like we are incompetent.

Fantastic experience: I have lived at this address for 11 yrs. They're great.

Fantastic experience: Friendly and very helpful, they take care of all the maintenance and repairs didn’t have to worry about getting the house fix up myself well recommended

Fantastic experience: We are in our second year and they have been great!!

Fantastic experience: We've been them for over a year, now. They are great! Very responsive. Very helpful. Very fair. Highly recommend!

Fantastic experience: No more worries Real Property Management Steel City gets it done thanks to Ms.Dickerson. 6 years with company line of communication never a problem professional kind and knowledgeable nothing but praise your hard work does not go unnoticed thanks again.

Fantastic experience: I recommend anyone that is looking for a home or an apartment here. Edna helped us through the process of getting into our apartment. The process was nice and easy I recommend anyone to this company. Me and my wife are extremely satisfied

Fantastic experience: Very friendly and helpful staff

Fantastic experience: Very helpful very friendly staff

Fantastic experience: A.J. has been amazing to work with. No matter the problem she finds the solution. Always pleasant and resonsive.

Fantastic experience: Amazing company to rent from! Super helpful and works with tenants.

Fantastic experience: A great management agency. I have referred other people seeking rentals. Excellent client service, with anything I need. Also I receive a quick response to resolve any issues I may have as a tenant.

Fantastic experience: Fantastic gentleman that showed a place to me. He was very professional and even joked with me a little. So far so good and I'm extremely pleased with the whole company at this time.

Negative experience: BEWARE!! I would like to warn homeowners about this business, and if you already are using their service, their book keeping and programs are always incorrect and changing. Make sure to do your due diligence to monitor your monthly statements. I am not sure where these 5 star reviews came from, maybe from the losers that she helps get into our homes. I was a homeowner and they managed my property very poorly. Lesha lied to me when I started asking about charges on my statement. Then she fired herself when I called her out on the matter. She did not do a full background check on the people that moved in to my property. hey Lesha, do you know that it only cost $28 a month to find out if they have criminal records, have left other properties without paying? Maybe you should do thorough background checks. I am still waiting for the money that Property Management did not collect!

Fantastic experience: RPM worked with my family and I to get into a home fast due to unexpected circumstances. They were very understanding and when some issues came up on RPM’s end they took ownership and made it up to us. We couldn’t be happier in our new home!

Fantastic experience: Real property management has gone above and beyond time and time again, it's a privilege and an honor to have their team helping me through all of the unforeseen challenges of renting a home. Thank you so much!

Fantastic experience: Edna was very helpful

Fantastic experience: Staff was very helpful and attentive. They made the moving process much easier for me.

Fantastic experience: We had the opportunity to work with Steel City, and while we didn’t end up renting from them, we really appreciated the time and effort they took to show us several properties. The team was professional and even went out of their way to recommend some great local spots to eat, which made the whole experience more enjoyable. Their local knowledge and friendly approach stood out—we’d definitely consider working with them again in the future.

Fantastic experience: They we’re very professional and communicative when it comes to your needs.

Fantastic experience: I’m very happy with this property management company. They are always available when I need assistance and they work around your schedule for inspections. Thanks AJ for making my inspection so smooth and simple today it was the easiest thing I dealt with all month.

Positive experience: Very friendly and curious associate. Very helpful with navigating help with debris clean up and tenant relations.

Fantastic experience: I've been thoroughly impressed with Lesha and her team at Real Property Management Steel City for their excellent handling of my rental property. A special shout-out goes to AJ, who has been doing a truly great job with all aspects of property maintenance and coordination. Her efficiency and attention to detail have made managing my rental stress-free. Highly recommend their services!

Fantastic experience: I'm loving my new property management. They are very professional and willing to accommodate our family.

Positive experience: Other than some weird little bits about how deposit is done, how locations are listed, and being unsure who to call, how, and when... and some minor issues with understanding how certain processes of theirs work, they were kind, always available, got us a place quick, and we're patient and understanding with us. Overall, some werd vibes and a sort of mismatched process... but quick as can be and very kind to boot. They don't waste any time on BS.

Fantastic experience: RPM has been very helpful and just overall great! AJ is very helpful and is always professional providing the best advice. I appreciate you!

Fantastic experience: As a chosen subctractor for Real Property for the last 2 years has been an amazing experience. Real Property Management owners to the staff take their job seriously. What's nice is the line of communication at its best to work out a resolution to meet expectations to all included. I give much thanks to Carlo in the Maintenance Department. It has been with great pleasure to work along with Carlo. He listens with great detail, gives good feedback, follows up when it comes to W.O.'s and suggestions. What tops it? Knowing when I call to hear Carlo's pleasant voice with calmness and and with a joyful sound simply makes up for a hectic day ahead. To be a successful business comes with superb customer service that is the glue that holds it together. Again, Pro Lawn Care & Landscaping, LLC appreciate working along side a fantastic team of people! Thank you always for choosing us! RoseMarie

Fantastic experience: I had a great experience with the company as a whole. I did bump into property issues however the staff was very professional in getting all issues resolved... I do recommend Real Property Management Steel City for your rental needs!

Negative experience: I would never recommend this property management company. The owner placed a tenant in my property that ruined multiple things and had to get evicted, and the property manager didn’t do anything to make it right or recoup losses for me. Their fees are also out of control. AVOID AVOID AVOID They will place bad tenants!!!

Negative experience: trust me I read the lease and this is one of the most insane things that had ever happend to me. how can we go about getting the house and it already was taken care of poorly when we arrived, and when we left after takeing care of the property for 2 years and leaving the house pretty much the same way we found it we get charged an extra $1700 on top of our deposit($1900) for cleaning and repairs and then never provided an itemized list as stated in their deposition

Fantastic experience: Lesha and Team are friendly and knowledgeable.

Fantastic experience: Lesha is extremely knowledgeable about property management and very helpful!

Fantastic experience: Lesha was super helpful and able to provide some great insights!

Fantastic experience: Kesha, thank you so much for the helpful advice! It is great working with you!

Fantastic experience: Very positive and helpful. They take care of all of the needs in a timely manner.

Fantastic experience: They are awesome! They helped navigate the entire process. I am out of state but I feel my property is in great hands!

Fantastic experience: I've been a tenant here for a couple of years. Everyone that I have dealt with has been professional and easy to communicate with. They have been diligent in completing maintenance requests quickly and correctly. Overall they have been great to rent from and easy to work with. I would recommend them for anyone looking for a rental in Pueblo.

Negative experience: Was rehoused due to mold and told to put a card on file in case of damage and that no funds would be taken off my account. Was then charged twice the amount of the room and out 500 dollars in the middle of a snowstorm. When I asked for help I was told to “rearrange” the due dates of my bills or they could take it off rent. Was also hung up on by Leesha when I asked her to help me fix this problem. She responded “I’ll just do it myself.” As if I’m asking her to do something out of her job description or asking her to fix a problem that wasn’t caused by her employees. When the original leak happened no body was sent out until 24 hours later and we cleaned up all the water ourselves. Had to buy a pump and broke our shot vac. The contractors they sent out didn’t need to do any work and stated we saved them 900 dollars as we did it ourselves. Kesha credited 100 dollars when we had already lost 200+. We Get no updates unless I call and every time I call Lesha is “in meetings” (all day) and never able to talk. Very unprofessional. On top of all of this they have tried to blame us various times for the mold. Every contractor they’ve sent out has showed us that this mold was a previous issue that was covered up. Even the pipe was patched over. Newest contractors discovered additional mold and were told to just deal with the new current mold that was found. Last time we were rehoused due to previous tenants illegally wiring electricity and lost almost 1000 in call offs due to work, rehousing every 3 days as they refused to book an Airbnb for longer than that time frame and all the meat and groceries lost. Was told to send an email regarding loses and never heard anything back besides they’ve done all they’re legally obligated to do.

Fantastic experience: They go a great job for us with our properties.

Fantastic experience: Aurora is a great agent!! She keeps me up to date on my property showings, where we’re at with lease agreement progress, and just has great communication all around. She even went out of her way to help get a lockbox on the property to make the first showing happen. Very impressed!!

Negative experience: I hired this company to manage my property about a year ago. It seemed every month they were charging for repairs to my house that I was completely unaware of at a rate much higher than if I hired somebody myself. They informed me I needed a full roof replacement that would cost $10,000. But after talking to my insurance adjuster he informed me only about a dozen shingles needed to be replaced for $1,000. They also charged me $437 for a water heater valve replacement, then informed me not even six months later that the entire water heater needed to be replaced for $2,200. After communicating with the renters directly they informed me the water heater was working just fine. They also took the entirety of the first two months rent from me because they did unnecessary repairs that I did not approve of before the tenants moved in. The owner Lesha never seems to be available because she is taking a vacation every single week it seems. So it’s impossible to get anything done because she’s the only person in the company that can approve things, yet she’s never there. In total they charged me over $8,000 in just under a year. Completely greedy business practices. Do not hire these people.